What is a Weighted Scoring?

Ruben Buijs
2 minutes • Aug 10, 2023 • Product Management

Weighted scoring is a powerful technique used in product management to objectively evaluate and prioritize different features, ideas, or projects based on their importance and impact. It involves assigning weights or values to various criteria or factors and then calculating a score for each item based on these weights. This method helps product managers make informed decisions and allocate resources effectively.

Examples

Let's say a product manager needs to decide which new features to prioritize for the next product release. They can use weighted scoring to evaluate each feature based on criteria such as customer demand, business value, development effort, and technical feasibility. By assigning weights to these criteria, the product manager can calculate a score for each feature, enabling them to prioritize and focus on the most valuable ones.

For instance, if a product manager is developing a mobile app and wants to improve user experience, they can use weighted scoring to evaluate potential enhancements. They might assign a higher weight to criteria like usability and performance, while giving lower weights to factors like aesthetics or social media integration. By applying weights and calculating scores, they can identify the most impactful improvements to prioritize.

Importance

Weighted scoring is crucial in product management as it provides a structured and data-driven approach to decision-making. It eliminates biases and subjectivity by considering multiple factors and assigning appropriate weights to them. This method helps product managers make informed choices based on a clear understanding of the relative importance and impact of different options.

By utilizing weighted scoring, product managers can avoid making decisions solely based on personal preferences or opinions. Instead, they can objectively evaluate and compare various features or projects, ensuring that resources are allocated to initiatives that align with the overall product strategy and deliver the most value to customers and the business.

How to Use It

To effectively use weighted scoring, product managers can follow these steps:

  1. Identify criteria: Determine the key factors that are relevant to the decision at hand. These criteria should align with the product strategy and goals.

  2. Assign weights: Assign relative weights to each criterion based on their importance. The sum of all weights should be 100% to maintain a proper balance.

  3. Rate each item: Evaluate each feature, idea, or project against the criteria and rate them on a predefined scale (e.g., 1-10).

  4. Calculate scores: Multiply the ratings of each item by their corresponding weights and sum the results to obtain a weighted score for each item.

  5. Prioritize: Sort the items based on their weighted scores in descending order. This prioritized list helps in making informed decisions and allocating resources effectively.

Useful Tips

  • Keep the number of criteria manageable: Too many criteria can make the evaluation process complex and time-consuming. Focus on the most critical factors that truly impact the success of the product.

  • Involve stakeholders: Gather input from various stakeholders such as customers, developers, and business leaders when defining criteria and assigning weights. This ensures a well-rounded perspective and buy-in from all parties involved.

  • Regularly update weights: As market conditions, business goals, or customer needs change, it's important to review and adjust the weights assigned to criteria. Regularly revisiting and updating the weights helps to maintain the relevance and accuracy of the scoring model.

  • Consider trade-offs: Weighted scoring provides a holistic view of different options, but it's essential to consider trade-offs between criteria. Sometimes, a feature with a lower score in one area might be more valuable overall due to its impact on other factors.

FAQ

Weighted scoring is a quantitative method used in product management to prioritize features or projects based on their importance or value.
Weighted scoring assigns weights or values to different criteria or factors and calculates a score for each feature or project based on those weights. The higher the score, the higher the priority.
Weighted scoring helps product managers make informed decisions by considering multiple factors and their relative importance. It ensures that resources are allocated to the most valuable features or projects.
Using weighted scoring allows for objective and transparent prioritization. It helps align product strategy with business goals, increases stakeholder satisfaction, and optimizes resource allocation.
Weights are assigned based on the relative importance of criteria or factors. Product managers can use different methods like pairwise comparison, 1-10 scale, or percentage allocation to assign weights.
Yes, weighted scoring can be applied to various types of products or projects, regardless of their complexity or industry. It is a flexible method that can accommodate different evaluation criteria.
No, weighted scoring is an ongoing process in product management. As priorities and market conditions change, product managers need to reassess and update the weights and scores regularly.
Some challenges include defining accurate evaluation criteria, ensuring consensus among stakeholders on weights, and obtaining reliable data for scoring. It requires effective communication and collaboration.
Yes, there are many product management software tools that offer weighted scoring features. These tools automate the calculation and visualization of scores, making the process more efficient.
Weighted scoring is a data-driven approach that complements intuition and experience. While it provides objective insights, product managers should still consider their expertise and market knowledge when making final decisions.

Article by

Ruben Buijs

Ruben is the founder of ProductLift. I employ a decade of consulting experience from Ernst & Young to maximize clients' ROI on new Tech developments. I now help companies build better products

Table of contents

  1. Examples
  2. Importance
  3. How to Use It
  4. Useful Tips
  5. Related Terms

Ship features your users (really) want.
Collect feedback, prioritize ideas, and build a product your customers love with AI-powered tools for feedback boards, roadmaps, changelogs, and knowledge bases.

Get Started for Free

The faster, easier way to capture user feedback at scale

Join over 3,051 product managers and see how easy it is to build products people love.

Did you know 80% of software features are rarely or never used? That's a lot of wasted effort.

SaaS software companies spend billions on unused features. Last year, it was $29.5 billion.

We saw this problem and decided to do something about it. Product teams needed a better way to decide what to build.

That's why we created ProductLift - to put all feedback in one place, helping teams easily see what features matter most.

In the last four years, we've helped over 3,051 product teams (like yours) double feature adoption and halve the costs. I'd love for you to give it a try.

Ruben Buijs

Founder & Digital Consultant